How to Protect Family Heirlooms Without Spending a Fortune

Smart coverage for irreplaceable jewelry—without appraisals, deductibles, or breaking the bank

You Can’t Replace Your Grandmother’s Necklace. But You Can Protect It.

There are certain things that don’t leave your home often. A ring your mom wore every day. The bracelet your grandfather gave your grandmother on their 50th anniversary. A locket with someone’s initials—maybe yours, maybe someone long gone.

These items may not be worth a fortune. They might not even be worth much at all on paper. But emotionally? They’re priceless. Which is why, for so many of us, the thought of losing them—through theft, damage, or even something as simple as a misplaced bag—is a quiet, nagging fear we carry around.

Still, let’s be honest: insuring them often feels like a hassle. Too expensive. Too confusing. Too many hoops. So we hesitate. We procrastinate. And we leave these irreplaceable pieces unprotected.

But the truth is, there are simple, cost-effective ways to insure family jewelry—without getting lost in forms, appraisals, and recurring fees. You just have to know where to look.

The Problem: Jewelry That’s Priceless in Meaning, But Modest in Value

Heirlooms sit in an odd space. They’re usually not the biggest diamond in your collection. They're not a brand-new Cartier watch or a luxury purchase made last week. More often, they’re smaller. A little older. Maybe a little worn.

But that’s what makes them meaningful.

Still, when you try to insure them, insurers tend to care more about dollar value than sentimental value. If it’s worth less than a few thousand dollars, it might not seem “worth” the paperwork. You’re asked to get an appraisal (which costs money). Then you’re quoted a recurring annual premium (more money). Then you realize you’ll have to pay a deductible if anything ever happens (even more money).

So you think: is it even worth it?

Why These Pieces Are More Vulnerable Than You Think

It’s easy to assume the necklace in the back of your drawer is safe. And maybe it is—for now. But family jewelry is often the most at risk precisely because it gets forgotten.

Here are just a few of the ways heirlooms get lost or damaged:

• Theft – Burglars often go straight for jewelry boxes. And unlike new purchases, heirlooms aren’t always documented or photographed.
• Travel mishaps – You pack light, throw a ring into your purse for a wedding weekend, and suddenly it’s missing.
• Cleaning accidents – Harsh chemicals, dropped stones, or pieces knocked into the sink. It happens more often than people admit.
• Fire or water damage – Jewelry may not be the first thing you think of in a natural disaster, but once it’s gone, it’s gone.
• Accidental disposal – Sounds ridiculous, right? And yet—how many times have people thrown out a tissue, a bag, a towel, and realized too late it was hiding something small and precious?

It’s not just about theft or “bad neighborhoods.” It’s about everyday life. Jewelry is small, delicate, and—when it matters most—impossible to replace emotionally.

The Hidden Cost of Doing Nothing

Here’s what many people don’t realize: traditional homeowners insurance often doesn’t cover individual jewelry items adequately. Or at all.

And even when it does, it’s rarely tailored to heirlooms. Coverage is capped. Deductibles are high. You’ll need documentation (like an appraisal). And the replacement you get might be based on some abstract “market value” calculation—not the emotional value that piece held.

Some insurers will offer a replacement that matches the stone size, but not the design. Others give store credit at a specific jeweler. Almost none account for the fact that this was your mother’s, or that your grandfather had it engraved in a specific script that’s no longer used.

So even with insurance, you can be left feeling like you lost it twice.

Why Traditional Jewelry Insurance Doesn’t Always Make Sense for Heirlooms

Let’s break this down.

Most traditional jewelry insurance policies are built for financial assets, not emotional ones. They're optimized for high-end diamonds, modern purchases, and resale value. Which is fair—but that makes them overkill for most family pieces.

Here’s what you’re usually asked to do:

• Get a formal appraisal, even for a $1,500 necklace.
• Pay an annual premium, often 1–2% of the item’s value.
• Renew every year, or risk a lapse in coverage.
• Pay a deductible, often $250–$1,000, before receiving anything.
• Wait on paperwork, approvals, and sometimes fight to get cash instead of credit.

For a $2,800 piece, you could easily spend $75–$100 a year, plus appraisal fees every few years. Over a decade, that’s over $1,000 spent just to keep it insured—and you’d still be short on a full replacement if it’s lost.

Now ask yourself: is that really sustainable for every ring, pendant, or watch in your family collection?

A Simpler, Smarter Solution: ONCE Insurance

This is where ONCE comes in.

ONCE was built around a different kind of customer. Someone who wants to protect what matters—but doesn’t want to overpay, overthink, or get stuck in an endless cycle of renewals.

Here’s how it works:

• One payment covers you for five full years. No subscriptions. No annual bills.
• No appraisals required for items valued up to $5,000. You simply select a reasonable coverage amount.
• No deductible. That means if something happens, you receive the full amount you insured.
• No stress. Everything is done online in minutes. No phone calls, no paperwork.

And here’s the kicker: most ONCE customers save up to 35% compared to what they would have paid over five years with a traditional insurer. That adds up—especially when you have multiple heirlooms you want to protect.

Real-World Example: A Tale of Two Necklaces

Let’s compare.

Item: A gold and pearl necklace passed down from your grandmother, estimated value: $3,000.

Traditional coverage would cost you $325+ over 5 years, with a payout of $2,500 at best. ONCE would cost you less than half—and you’d get the full amount if you needed it.

What Kinds of Heirlooms Can You Insure?

You might be wondering if ONCE is only for engagement rings or flashy watches. Not at all.

If your item is:

• Valued under $5,000
• Personally owned (not commercial inventory)
• Not an extremely rare or collectible investment piece
• And you want simple, no-hassle coverage

Then yes—it probably qualifies.

Common heirlooms people insure with ONCE:

• A grandfather’s cufflinks
• A vintage ring passed from mother to daughter
• A gold charm bracelet from the 1970s
• A pearl brooch from a great-aunt
• A signet ring engraved with family initials
• A necklace from a bar mitzvah or wedding decades ago

Even if it’s “just a $1,200 piece,” it’s likely worth far more emotionally. And that’s exactly why it deserves protection.

What If You Don’t Know the Exact Value?

That’s okay. You’re not alone. Many people don’t have receipts, records, or recent appraisals for older family jewelry. In fact, that’s part of the problem with traditional insurers—they require documentation many people simply don’t have.

ONCE takes a more intuitive approach. When you go to insure an item, you select an amount you believe reflects its value (within a reasonable range). You’ll be asked to describe the piece and upload a photo, but that’s it. No trip to the gemologist. No formal paperwork. No waiting.

It’s built for real people, real items, and real situations.

A Bit of Peace of Mind—Without the Price Tag

Let’s face it—most of us are already over-insured in some areas and under-insured in others. We pay for extended warranties on headphones, but haven’t protected a ring we hope to pass down someday.

And that’s not a criticism. It’s just reality.

But when it comes to family heirlooms, the math and the meaning both point in one direction: protect what matters most, with a solution that respects both your wallet and your memories.

ONCE gives you peace of mind without the burden of ongoing costs, renewals, or red tape. You pay once, and then you can forget about it—until and unless you need it.

Final Thoughts: Insurance That Makes Sense

It’s easy to dismiss insurance as boring or unnecessary. Until something is lost.

Then, the equation flips. You’d give anything to undo it. But while you can’t recover the full emotional weight of a lost heirloom, you can avoid the financial hit—and ensure you’re not left empty-handed.

For less than the price of a nice dinner out, you can protect something you hope to pass on someday. A small gesture that says: “This matters. This story continues.”

So take five minutes today. Open your drawer. Look at what’s inside. Choose one or two pieces that matter most. And give them the protection they deserve.

You’ll feel better knowing they’re safe. And one day, someone else will thank you for it.

These pieces have lasted generations. Give them the protection to last a few more.

‍
Insure your family jewelry today with ONCE—one payment, five years, zero stress.
No appraisals. No deductibles. No surprises.

Get a quote for your family heirloom today! 

‍